CDC Recommends Older People Get Another COVID-19 Vaccine

Critics say the recommendation is not supported.
CDC Recommends Older People Get Another COVID-19 Vaccine
A health care worker prepares a COVID-19 vaccine in New York City in a file photograph. (Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)
Zachary Stieber
By Zachary Stieber, Senior Reporter
3/5/2024
Updated:
3/5/2024
0:00

People 65 and older should get another dose of the latest round of COVID-19 vaccines, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

The recommendation “allows older adults to receive an additional dose of this season’s COVID-19 vaccine to provide added protection,” Dr. Mandy Cohen, head of the CDC, said in a recent statement.

“Most COVID-19 deaths and hospitalizations last year were among people 65 years and older. An additional vaccine dose can provide added protection that may have decreased over time for those at highest risk,” she added.

Since the vaccines were first rolled out in late 2020, the CDC has repeatedly advised Americans to get doses after initially saying only one or two were needed.

The latest round of vaccines, which target the XBB.1.5. virus subvariant, were cleared and recommended for people aged 5 and up in the fall of 2023 after previous versions failed to convey lasting protection. The XBB.1.5. strain is no longer present in the United States, CDC sequencing shows.

In a study published in its quasi-journal in February, the CDC reported on an examination of health care records for adults who visited an emergency department, went to an urgent care facility, or were hospitalized with COVID-19-like illness. Officials estimated that seniors who received one of the new shots—when compared to seniors who did not, including the previously vaccinated—had a peak of 49 percent protection against emergency department or urgent care visits, but that the protection waned to 37 percent over time, with protection estimated to be slightly better against hospitalization.
Another recent study, which has not been peer-reviewed, estimated protection from the new vaccines to be 50 percent against infection.

Some experts have warned against relying on such observational data, noting that the data do not prove vaccines confer protection.

The CDC did not provide any research on the safety of giving seniors two shots within one year.

“Where is the science backing up the CDC’s claim that it is safe to give every American over age 65 a COVID shot twice in the same year? Once again, policy is preceding the science and Americans are left to wonder why they should trust government vaccine recommendations,” Barbara Loe Fisher, co-founder and president of the National Vaccine Information Center, told The Epoch Times in an email.

Panel Advice

The CDC’s guidance came after its advisory panel advised it in an 11–1 vote to recommend another dose for seniors.

The advisory panel’s decision came after a lengthy discussion about whether to say older people “may” get the shots or if they “should” do so.

“Most people are coming in either wanting the vaccine or not,” said Dr. Jamie Loehr, a committee member and family doctor in Ithaca, New York. “I am trying to make it easier for providers to say, ‘Yes, we recommend this.’”

Just 22 percent of adults and 13 percent of children have received one of the new shots, according to CDC data. The vaccination rate is higher for adults 65 and older, at nearly 42 percent.

The current vaccines from Pfizer and Novavax were cleared with no trial data, while Moderna’s shot was tested on just 50 humans. Pfizer has since reported favorable results from a trial of 412 participants.

A new round of vaccines is expected to be cleared later in 2024. U.S. officials have shifted the COVID-19 vaccine program to the model used for influenza. The model typically involves updating the vaccines once a year.

Dr. David Canaday, a Case Western Reserve University infectious diseases expert who studies COVID-19 in older people, noted that uptake has gone down for each new COVID-19 vaccine that has been cleared and recommended.

“People are tired of getting all these shots all the time,” said Dr. Canaday, who does not serve on the advisory committee. “We have to be careful about over-recommending the vaccine.”

The Associated Press contributed to this report. 
Zachary Stieber is a senior reporter for The Epoch Times based in Maryland. He covers U.S. and world news. Contact Zachary at [email protected]
twitter
truth
Related Topics